Groundwork complains to the European Commission for lack of management at Killarney National Park

Jan 03

Groundwork complains to the European Commission for lack of management at Killarney National Park

Published on: 3 January 2018

Rhododendron at Killarney National Park. Image: Groundwork.

Groundwork has made a formal complaint to the European Commission that the National Parks and Wildlife Service (NPWS) and Department of Culture, Heritage & the Gaeltacht (DCHG) have failed to protect the Oak woods in Killarney National Park from becoming re-infested with Rhododendron ponticum.

Groundwork is a voluntary group which ran work camps removing Rhododendron from 1981 until 2009 in Killarney National Park, with the support of the Irish Wildlife Trust and NPWS.

During that time, approximately 40% of the Oak woods were cleared of Rhododendron and maintained in a cleared condition by Groundwork. Our methods were scientifically proven, successful and are described in the NPWS publication, Irish Wildlife Manual No. 33.

Rhododendron ponticum poses a significant threat to native Irish woodlands by preventing regeneration and displacing native flora.

As a result of NPWS mismanagement, the most biologically rich areas of the Killarney Oak woods are now significantly and rapidly deteriorating, and no management plans have been implemented to address the problem. We believe this constitutes a breach of Articles 6(1) & 6(2) of the Habitats Directive.

The last published Killarney National Park Management plan (2005-2009), was never fully implemented and its Rhododendron management objectives were ignored.

As early as 2005, Groundwork expressed concern regarding the effectiveness of the NPWS approach to Rhododendron management. Monitoring of the Killarney Oak woods by Groundwork since 2013 has produced abundant photographic evidence that seed production has resumed in all of these woodlands and that they have now reverted to uncleared status which is a deterioration of a qualifying Annex 1 Habitat and therefore represents a breach of Article 6(2) of the Habitats Directive.

Since 2010, NPWS has refused Groundwork’s offers of assistance in Killarney National Park.

Using Access to information on the Environment (AIE) Regulations, Groundwork uncovered documents from both NPWS and Trinity College Dublin’s Botany Department which confirm our findings in relation to the expansion of Rhododendron in woodlands that had been previously free of infestation.

The previous Minister of DCHG stated in 2017 that, “€700,000 has been spent eradicating Rhododendron in Killarney National Park since 2011, and €240,000 has been budgeted for this year.”

It should be noted that Groundwork cleared and maintained c. 40% of the Killarney National Park Oak woods at a cost of under c.€20,000 a year. The model of Rhododendron clearance we pioneered and perfected over 30 years was both effective and successful. We were a successful volunteer programme which should have been used to complement clearance by Park staff and Contractors.

The methods employed by Killarney National Park to clear Rhododendron have failed due to a lack of a systematic and scientific approach to Rhododendron clearance.

We would hope that a decision from the European Commission would help the NPWS and DCHG implement an effective, scientifically sound Rhododendron management programme.

Groundwork Chairperson Trevor Halpin says, “Groundwork have blown the whistle in relation to the mismanagement of Rhododendron in Killarney National Park. Unfortunately, inaction by DCHG and NPWS has allowed previously cleared woodlands to become re-infested with Rhododendron.  We call on the DCHG and NPWS to once again allow science to guide Rhododendron management in Killarney”  END

CONTACT: Groundwork Chairperson, Trevor Halpin on 086 1706268 for more details.